DRAFT · this page is currently under construction.
ApertureLab's motion estimation and back-projection were applied to stave data that ApertureLab did not generate: the University of Bath's simulated interferometric synthetic aperture sonar (InSAS) record of the SS Thistlegorm wreck [1, 2]. With sway and heave estimated from the echoes alone, the estimated track ends 1.8 mm to port of the true track and 6.8 mm below it after 200 m, and the image formed with it has a magnitude correlation of 0.9995 with the image formed with the true track. The vehicle in this record flies a straight line, so the result shows that the estimator reports no motion where there is none, in a scene where a wreck rising about 17 m from the seabed and its shadows fill much of the swath. The second part of the page applies the same estimator to a sonar simulated along a recorded vehicle track over a seabed with relief, and compares it with the navigation the vehicle's sensors report.
Data
Thomas and Hunter simulated the record from a three-dimensional model of the wreck on a textured seafloor, a scene of 220 m by 135 m, with a point-based scattering model and ray-traced occlusion [1, 2]. The sonar is similar to the 300 kHz MUSCLE system of the NATO Centre for Maritime Research and Experimentation. The data are distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. No noise and no motion were added to the record for this page.
Array
The receivers are 33 mm apart, so the phase centers are 16.5 mm apart. The vehicle advances 0.5445 m between pings, which is 33 phase-center spacings on a row of 36, and three phase centers of each ping therefore coincide with three of the next. The echoes received at coincident phase centers differ only by what the vehicle did between the two pings, and the motion estimate is made from that difference. The transmitter measures 50 mm along the track and each receiver 33 mm.
Measurements
Over the seabed the correlation coefficient is 0.99 and the time delay falls smoothly with range. On a straight track that delay is not zero: the two receivers of a shared phase center sit at different distances from the transmitter, which leaves a delay that depends on range alone. The motion model accounts for it, and over the seabed the measured and modeled delays agree to within 0.008 µs.
Two kinds of window hold no seabed echo: those before the first return at 52 m, and those in the two shadows of the wreck, which appear in the maps between 90 m and 155 m. The record's level there is about 40 dB below the seabed's, yet the channels still correlate above 0.66 in places, with a delay near zero that does not describe the vehicle. These windows are excluded by their level before the solve. The level the seabed returns at each range, and its spread, are read from the record itself. Of the 89,181 windows in the estimation interval, 26,934 were excluded as holding no seabed echo and 62,241 were used.
Result
Sway and heave velocities are solved for all pings jointly by least squares on the time delay estimates, first with the delays from the correlation magnitude and then with the delays refined by the correlation phase, following [3]. The image formation page describes the chain this step belongs to.
The error in both axes grows in a straight line, which is a constant velocity bias: 0.05 mm/s in sway and 0.19 mm/s in heave, on a vehicle moving at 5.4 m/s. The position error passes one eighth of a wavelength after about 125 pings in sway and about 35 in heave. A constant velocity bias displaces the image and does not defocus it.
Images
Estimated navigation
True navigation
Estimated navigation
True navigation
Motion
The Bath record holds no motion to recover. To measure the estimator where motion is present, a sonar of the same class was simulated in ApertureLab along a recorded vehicle track, together with the navigation its sensors would report. Three tracks are compared: the recorded track, which the simulation takes as true; the track dead reckoned from the sensors; and the track estimated from the echoes.
Measurements
The time delay follows the vehicle's sideways velocity from ping to ping and is nearly uniform across range, because the seabed is seen at shallow grazing angles. The median correlation coefficient in the estimation interval is 0.74, lower than on a track whose phase centers coincide, and 34,757 of its 52,100 windows are used.
Result
The root-mean-square velocity error of the estimate is 1.5 mm/s in surge, 2.0 mm/s in sway and 7.8 mm/s in heave, against 3.0, 2.8 and 3.8 mm/s for the sensor navigation. The two errors differ in character: the sensor error changes from one ping to the next, while the error of the estimate varies more slowly. Focus depends on the error across one synthetic aperture. At 45 m of range the sensor navigation leaves a phase error of 2.6 rad across the aperture once its mean and slope are removed, and the estimate leaves 1.0 rad.
Dead reckoned over the whole record, the estimate lies further from the true track than the sensor navigation does: 12.8 mm against 7.6 mm in surge, 14.7 mm against 6.5 mm in sway and 63.7 mm against 55.9 mm in heave. A slowly varying position error displaces the image and does not defocus it. The heave error of the estimate is attributed to the motion model, which assumes a horizontal seabed where this one varies by 2.7 m.
Images
Sensor navigation
Estimated navigation
Sensor navigation
Estimated navigation
Scope
Sources